Dissection

Assalaamu'alaikum,

Dissecting Human Dead Bodies for Medical Purposes

In the first place, we would like to note that Islam cares much for a person whether dead or alive. Jabir Ibn `Abdullah (may Allah be pleased with him) said: “One day we accompanied the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) in a funeral of a person. When we reached the graves, we sat down. The gravedigger brought out a bone- of a leg or another organ- and began to break it. The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said: ‘Do not break it, for breaking this bone, even after the death of its owner, is like breaking it while he/she is alive.’” (Reported by Malik, Ibn Majah and Abu Dawud)

Handling the issue of dissecting human dead body for medical purposes or the like, Sheikh `Attiya Saqr, former Head of Al-Azhar Fatwa Committee, issues the following fatwa:
In fact, there is no religious text tackling directly the issue of using the organs of the dead for medical or scientific research. The issue is controversial among Muslim scholars; each making his own Ijtihad (Personal Reasoning).

In the fatwa issued by the Egyptian House of Fatwa on 31st Oct. 1937 on the issue of dissecting the belly of a dead person who swallowed an amount of money, it is stated:
The Hanafi scholars permit dissecting the belly of such a person if the money belongs to another person and the deceased left no money that can be given to the owner. The simple reason for this is that the right of a human being takes priority over the right of Allah and the right of the wrongdoer. It goes without saying that it was a wrong thing done by the deceased by unjustifiably taking a person’s money.

The view of the Shafi`i scholars is that they permit dissecting the belly of a dead person for the purpose of taking out money without giving further details on the issue. The same view adopted by Maliki jurist, Sahnun, while Ahmad holds the opposite view.

As for opening the belly of a dead mother for the very purpose of taking out the baby, the Hanafi scholars permit it if the baby is known to be alive, for this will help in saving the life of a human being. The same view is upheld by Shafi`i scholars while the Malikis and the Hanbalis disallow it.

The correct opinion is that the rules and the objectives of Shari`ah indicate that if there is a benefit behind opening the belly of a dead person, leading to establishing the cause of death or restoring back a right, then dissection is permissible in this case.

The Fatwa of late Sheikh Jadul-Haq `Ali Haq, former Grand Imam of Al-Azhar (may Allah bless his soul) also reads:
According to both Imam Abu Hanifah and Ash-Shafi`i, it is permissible to open the belly of a dead person, if there is a valid reason for doing so, such as taking out a living baby or valuable or precious thing (money or jewelry or the like) that the person has swallowed. The view of Malik and Ahmad is that it is allowable to do so in case of money and not in case of a baby. I myself support this view. To me, there is nothing wrong in opening the belly of a dead person so as to take out something valuable such as a living baby or money of considerable value.

As for using human organs after death, late Sheikh Jadul-Haq adds:

It is permissible, if the deceased is of unknown personality or family, to take his/her bodily organs and use it in treating another person or for medical research. All these are in fact very important and of general benefit for all Muslims.

Now, to the question of using the bodily organs of a dead person for research purposes. The Fatwa of Sheikh `Ikrimah Sabri, the Mufti of Al-Quds & the Khatib of Al-Aqsa Mosque, states:
Islam shows unprecedented care for the needs of man and the necessities of life. It makes it permissible to reveal the private parts of a male or a female in case of necessity. All this stems from the juristic rules: “Necessity dictates exceptions.” This rule is also governed by another rule that reads: “Necessities are duly estimated."

It is thus permissible to dissect the dead body of a person with the very aim of discovering diseases or finding out a treatment or knowing the functions of bodily organs and the component of human body. It is also permissible to resort to carry out this process for the purpose of knowing the reason that caused the death of a person, and this will be useful for homicidal investigation. Using the bodily parts of a dead person is also permissible for the students of medicine who do so as a way of training. However, this is to be carried out in a place specialized for that purpose and not open for everybody.
By and large, dissecting human dead bodies for medical research is permissible so long as the Islamic morals of preserving the body and confining the process to such medical purposes are maintained.

Elaborating on the issue of conducting postmortem, we would like to cite for you the following:
A postmortem is permissible if it is conducted for the right purpose. We can say that determining the cause of death, either when a crime is suspected or to enable medical students and their teachers to learn about the effects of certain diseases, is a legitimate purpose to carry out a postmortem. Many people are under the impression that postmortems are forbidden in Islam. It is certainly forbidden to show disrespect to or assault the dead body of any person. Islam forbids the disfigurement of enemy soldiers in battle. It would certainly not allow the cutting up of dead bodies for idle play. A legitimate purpose, however, is different. If a medical purpose is not legitimate, what is?

Source: www.islamicity. com

Dr. Muzzamil Siddiq, former President of Islamic Society of North America (ISNA), adds:
Dissection of the human bodies for the purpose of medical education is allowed in Islam. There is a basic rule in the Shari`ah that says: “What is necessary for the fulfillment of an obligation, becomes an obligation itself.” It is obligatory to treat people and perform surgeries on them when they need. To perform this obligation it is necessary to study human anatomy and for this purpose dissection has to be done as and when necessary.

It is, however, important that the bodies should be taken with the consent of the deceased or his/her relatives. If the deceased had no relative and his/her body was unclaimed, then such bodies can be used for the dissection purpose only with the permission of a local other legal authorities.

The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said: “The ruler (or the legal authority) is the guardian of him who has no guardian.” If a Muslim’s body is used for the dissection, then it should be washed. Funeral prayer should be performed before the dissection. After the dissection all the parts of the body should be collected in a bag and then they should be properly buried. I am told that some Muslim medical schools did follow this procedure.

However, stealing the bodies from the graveyards is prohibited. This is exactly a grave sin. A Muslim should neither steal a dead person’s body, nor should Muslim medical students buy or use such bodies. Those who have done that out of ignorance should make repentance to Allah and ask His forgiveness.

Excerpted, with slight modifications, from: www.pakistanilink. com

In conclusion, it is to be noted that scholars have a lot to say on the issue at hand, but as we have noticed the preponderant view is that dissecting human dead bodies is permissible on the condition that it is done while adhering to the Islamic regulations stated above which aim at maintaining the highest degree of security and safety of the body.

Kejadian Manusia

Saturday, May 9, 2009

Susahlah anatomi ni doktor.... macamana ni?

السلام عليكم

Apabila sahaja aku bersama pelajar-pelajar, soalan yang sama sahaja diajukan, "doktor, susah lah anatomi... ada cara yang lain yang lebih bagus tak?..."



Fikir-fikir semula... ya! Memang semua perkara pun kalau tak faham, semua jadi susah.. sebenarnya tiada jalan mudah menguasai ilmu ni melainkan dengan mengkajinya sendiri, berdiskusi dan menjawab soalan-soalan berkaitan. Pelajar-pelajar tidak seharusnya menyalahkan pensyarah sahaja sedangkan pelajar-pelajar harus membuat pembacaan dan kajian sendiri dan jika masih tidak memahaminya barulah terus merujuk kepada pensyarah. Pensyarah juga harus sentiasa meneruskan kajian dalam bidangnya masing-masing sambil memerhati dan mencari penemuan baru.

Kesilapan pelajar.

Pelajar perubatan, pergigian atau paramedik mempelajari anatomi sebagai sebahagian daripada subjek di universiti atau kolej perubatan. Antara kesilapan yang biasa dilihat di kalangan pelajar ialah mereka hanya mempelajari nota kuliah dan mengabaikan pengkajian yang lebih mendalam terhadap buku-buku pelajaran yang sedia ada untuk lebih memahami konsepnya dan fakta-fakta berkaitan. Alasan sebahagiannya ialah mereka tidak mempunyai masa untuk membacanya kerana perlu memberi perhatian kepada subjek lain seperti fisiologi, biokimia dan sebagainya.

Pada saya, soal masa bukanlah alasannya kerana saya juga melihat ada pelajar yang cemerlang.Saya akui ada pelajar yang sukar atau lambat memahami sesetengah topik, tetapi itu tidak bermakna anda mengambil mudah pelajaran anda.

Tiada jalan mudah

Subjek anatomi manusia kelihatan luarannya seperti sukar dan kompleks. Saya juga mengakui agak mengambil masa yang lama juga ketika menjadi pelajar di sekolah perubatan untuk memahami subjek ini. Ada beberapa perkara juga yang saya rasa boleh menjadi faktornya:

1. Faktor pensyarah

Ada sesetengah pelajar menghadapi kesukaran memahami bahasa Inggeris yang digunakan pensyarah ketika menyampaikan kuliah mereka. Bukan sahaja pensyarah warga asing malah pensyarah tempatan juga. Isi kandungan 'slide' kuliah mereka kadang-kadang terlalu padat atau terlalu ringkas sehingga pelajar sukar memahaminya dengan baik. Pemilihan gambar yang terlalu banyak label atau terlalu umum menyukarkan pelajar.

2. Faktor pelajar

Tidak saya nafikan pelajar sangat mengharapkan pembacaannya dipermudahkan oleh pensyarah, namun tiada jalan mudah bagi pelajar untuk menguasai pemahaman melainkan membuat nota sendiri.Percayalah, dengan membuat nota sendiri anda akan mudah memahaminya dan apabila anda mahu mengulangkajinya, anda boleh melakukan dengan masa yang singkat dan hafalan anda menjadi bertambah baik kerana anda tidak membacanya seperti kali pertama.

Anatomi itu mudah, janganlah memberatkannya.

wassalaam
Posted by at
Labels:

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

ISLAM

Salam Ukhuwwah